Soap dishes and dispensers: three ways to hold soap on the wall
Soap on a bathroom wall is held in one of three ways: a dish or shelf for a bar, a bottle holder for a pump bottle, or a dispenser with its own mechanism. This page covers all three, from Nero, Phoenix, Caroma, Fienza, Clark and Meir. It gives the sizes, the base metal, the warranty line and the clear space for each, so you can choose the type first and then the range. Each type has its own page, linked in the section where it belongs.
The three types compared
| Type | Holds | Where it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Soap dish or shelf | A bar of soap | A shower wall or a basin wall |
| Bottle holder | One to three pump bottles | A shower, a basin or a kitchen sink |
| Sensor dispenser | Liquid soap, dispensed on approach | A basin or a hob |
Choose the dish when the household uses bar soap and the bottle holder when it uses liquid soap. A dish is a fixed shelf and a bottle holder is a cradle, so the bottle holder asks you to keep the same bottle size, and the dish asks you to keep the bar out of standing water.
Soap dishes and shelves
| Dish | Length | Projection | Warranty line |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nero New Mecca | 174mm | 100mm | 10 years |
| Nero Bianca | 193mm | 93mm | 25 years |
| Nero Zen SS316L | 250mm | 90mm | 25 years |
| Phoenix Gloss | Fixed at 124mm | 80mm | 7 years for the product, 7 more for the finish |
| Phoenix Nuage | Not given | 82mm | Not given |
| Phoenix Vivid Slimline | Not given | 100mm | Not given |
| Phoenix Radii | 140mm | 111mm | 7 years |
| Caroma Liano II | 193mm, fixed at 150mm | 100mm | 20 years |
| Fienza Kaya soap shelf | 189mm, fixed at 134mm | 128mm | 5 years |
The projection is the figure that decides how it feels in a shower. The Gloss dish stands 80mm from the wall and the Kaya shelf 128mm, a gap of 48mm, so the Gloss is the one for a narrow shower and the Kaya for a wide one. The longest dishes are the 250mm Zen and the 193mm Bianca and Liano II, and the shortest is the 140mm Radii. For the fuller list of dishes from every maker, see soap dish holders.
Open dishes and drain channels
A bar of soap lasts longer when water can leave the dish. The Caroma Cosmo metal soap basket, 126mm, has an open design so no water is trapped in the dish, and it is made for shower or bath installations in Polished Chrome. The Fienza Tono soap shelf, 190mm, has a drain channel and high-strength mounting brackets in stainless steel, and the Fienza Empire Slim glass soap holder is 122mm long and 50mm high. Choose one of these when the dish sits in the line of the shower spray.
Bottle holders
| Holder | Size | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Nero Mecca single | 70mm high, 68mm projection | 304 stainless steel, 10 years |
| Nero Mecca double | 165mm long, 75mm projection | Two bottles side by side, 25 years |
| Nero Mecca triple | 250mm long, 75mm projection | 29.5mm bottle hole, 25 years |
| Nero Mecca triple with shelf | 410mm long, 90mm projection | 29.5mm bottle hole, 25 years |
| Caroma Liano II | 100mm high, 75mm projection, fixed at 48mm | Stainless steel, 20 years |
| Clark Round | Suits 500mL pump bottles | Matte Black, metal |
| Meir outdoor bracket | Takes a 28mm screw top | 316 stainless steel, lifetime warranty |
The bottle hole is the number to check. The Nero Mecca holders take a 29.5mm hole and the Meir bracket a 28mm screw top, so measure the top of your pump bottle before you order. Allow room above the tallest bottle so it can be lifted out, about 30mm to 50mm. The Clark Round holder suits the common 500mL pump bottle and works at a shower, a basin or a kitchen sink. See Nero soap bottle holders for the Nero range in full.
Sensor dispensers
The Nero Mecca sensor soap dispensers come in two mounts, hob mounted and wall mounted. Both are brass with a PVD finish and carry a 10 year warranty line. The hob mounted dispenser is 144mm high and the wall mounted one stands 139mm from the wall. They are battery powered, with an optional power adapter sold separately. For the full set of dispensers, see liquid soap dispensers.
What to use instead of a soap dish
A bottle holder or a dispenser replaces a dish when the household uses liquid soap. A holder keeps the bottle off the bench, takes the same refills and costs no extra counter space. Both avoid the question of where the bar drains, because there is no bar. Choose a holder when you want to refill from a larger bottle, and a dispenser when you want the hands-free option.
Base metal and process by maker
| Maker | Base metal | Finish |
|---|---|---|
| Nero Mecca, New Mecca and Bianca | 304 stainless steel | PVD |
| Nero Zen SS316L | 316L stainless steel | PVD |
| Nero Opal and Phoenix Radii, Nuage and Vivid Slimline | Brass | PVD |
| Phoenix Gloss | Stainless steel | PVD |
| Phoenix Radii SS 316 | Marine grade 316 stainless steel | Brushed, twin screw mounting plate |
| Caroma Liano II | Stainless steel | PVD |
| Fienza Kaya, Tono and Empire Slim | Stainless steel | PVD |
For a coastal or outdoor wall, choose the 316 builds: the Nero Zen, the Phoenix Radii SS 316 and the Meir bracket. Inside, the choice is the finish and the warranty line. See chrome, black and brushed nickel for the same finish across makers.
Finishes by range
The finish list is the quickest filter. Most ranges offer Chrome, Black, Brushed Nickel and Gunmetal, and the warm finishes are spread more thinly.
| Range | Finishes |
|---|---|
| Nero Mecca bottle holders | Chrome, Black, Brushed Nickel, Gunmetal, Gold, Brass, Bronze and Matte White on the single holder |
| Nero Bianca and New Mecca dishes | Chrome, Black, Brushed Nickel, Gunmetal, Gold, Brass and Bronze |
| Nero Zen SS316L and Opal dishes | Brushed Nickel, Gunmetal, Gold, Brass and Bronze, with no Chrome or Black |
| Phoenix Gloss | Chrome, Black, Brushed Nickel, Gunmetal, Gold, Brass and Bronze |
| Phoenix Nuage | Chrome, Brushed Nickel, Gunmetal and White |
| Caroma Liano II | Chrome, Black, Brushed Nickel, Gunmetal, Gold, Brass and Bronze |
| Fienza Kaya and Tono | Chrome, Black, Brushed Nickel, Gunmetal and Gold, with Brass on the Kaya |
| Caroma Cosmo | Chrome on the basket, Chrome and Black on the holder |
| Nero Mecca sensor dispensers | Chrome, Black, Brushed Nickel, Gunmetal, Gold and Bronze |
If you want Matte White, the Nero Mecca single bottle holder and the Phoenix Nuage dish are the two pieces here that offer it. For a warm finish on a dish, Nero, Phoenix, Caroma and Fienza all offer Gold, and the Fienza Kaya and Tono shelves have no Bronze where the others do.
Choosing by job
| Job | Start with | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A bar of soap in a shower spray | Caroma Cosmo basket or Fienza Tono shelf | Open basket and drain channel let water leave |
| A wide shower with room | Fienza Kaya soap shelf | 128mm deep and 189mm long |
| A narrow shower | Phoenix Gloss dish | Stands 80mm from the wall |
| Two or three pump bottles | Nero Mecca double or triple holder | 165mm and 250mm long, 29.5mm bottle hole |
| A coastal or outdoor wall | Nero Zen SS316L dish or the Meir 316 bracket | 316 stainless steel bodies |
| Hands-free liquid soap | Nero Mecca sensor dispenser | Hob or wall mounted, battery powered |
Fixing distance against overall length
A dish is longer on the wall than between its fixing points. The Caroma Liano II dish is 193mm long and fixed at 150mm, so the ends add 43mm, and the Fienza Kaya shelf is 189mm long and fixed at 134mm, which adds 55mm. The Phoenix Gloss dish fixes at 124mm. Mark the drill holes from the dish itself, and leave the extra length clear of the tap, the screen and the tile edge on each side.
The warranty lines run from 5 years on the Fienza pieces to lifetime on the Meir bracket and on the finish of the Phoenix Radii SS 316. Nero offers 10 years on most pieces and 25 on the Mecca double and triple holders, the Bianca dish and the Zen dish, and Caroma gives 20 years on the Liano II. Read the line on the piece you choose, because it differs even within one range.
Placing the dish or holder
Place the piece where the soap is used, within easy reach of the hand that uses it, and clear of the main spray in a shower. A dish needs 80mm to 128mm of clear space in front of the wall, depending on the range, and a holder 68mm to 90mm. Check the fixing distance on the spec before you drill, because it is shorter than the overall length.
For other accessories beside the soap, see toothbrush holders and shower and vanity shelves. The maker collections for Nero, Phoenix, Caroma and Fienza show every range, and bathroom accessories holds the full set.
Fit check before you order
- Choose the type first: a dish for a bar, a holder for a pump bottle, a dispenser for hands-free.
- Measure the top of your pump bottle against the hole in the holder.
- Read the projection against the shower or basin width.
- Compare the warranty lines, from 5 years to lifetime.
- Match the finish to the tapware.
Settle the type, then the range, then the finish.